David O’Reilly, an environment artist who spent 12 years at Rockstar, stated that Sony and Microsoft struggle to replicate Rockstar’s advantages, with the key difference lying in the long-term retention of personnel and knowledge. He believes that frequent layoffs not only drive away senior staff but also weaken the continuity of experience across projects.
According to O’Reilly, some major publishers lay off staff when demand drops and rehire once production ramps up again. While this approach aims to cut costs, it makes it difficult to quickly recover the institutional knowledge accumulated by the original team.
In his view, Rockstar has retained much of its “knowledge base” over the past 27 years, with many senior employees staying on, creating an advantage that other companies find hard to catch up with quickly. Claims that certain Xbox and PlayStation franchises weakened after key veteran employees left are judgments made by the article and interviewees; there is no evidence that these changes were solely caused by layoffs.
O’Reilly also noted that while Take-Two prioritizes profitability, it views Rockstar as a key asset and grants it significant creative freedom. The substantial budgets and resources available to Rockstar have also enabled the expansion of its projects' scale.

