A review article from Rock Paper Shotgun revisits the 2002 title Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven. The author argues that although Grand Theft Auto III had a greater impact on the open-world genre, the former's choice of a realistic approach was more like a preview of Rockstar's later works, with the Grand Theft Auto series gradually moving closer to this path with each installment.
Set during the Prohibition era, Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven tells the story of taxi driver Tommy Angelo joining the Salieri crime family. The game also uses environmental changes to depict the passage of time, including construction sites gradually being completed, used car dealerships opening as the economy recovers, and street vehicles changing with the years.
Several rules within the city also emphasize realism. Players receive police fines for speeding or running red lights, and can ride trams and elevated trains; when reloading, remaining bullets in the magazine are discarded along with it, and vehicles may run out of fuel during long drives.
The author mentions these designs alongside the cloud simulation, scent reactions, and fuel tank systems discussed in relation to GTA VI, but does not directly compare their technical scale. The article also argues that the series' protagonists and narratives have gradually become more mature and complex: Niko Bellic from Grand Theft Auto IV and Michael De Santa from Grand Theft Auto V are both richer characters than Claude, the silent protagonist of Grand Theft Auto III. The author believes that while Rockstar continues to push the genre forward, it is increasingly approaching the open-world path pioneered by Illusion Softworks in its early years.

