TGA 2026 has announced the nominees for all 30 awards. "Gothic Remake" received no nominations, sparking dissatisfaction among some Reddit users. The controversy mainly centers around the Best RPG nominee list.
This year's Best RPG nominees include "Final Fantasy: Resonance," "Fire Emblem: Weave of Fate," "Monster Hunter Stories 3: Twin Dragons of Destiny," "Blood of the Dawnwalker," and "Trails in the Sky Chapter 2." Some players pointed out that the selection did not exclude remakes of classic titles: "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time" made it into the Game of the Year nominees, and "Trails in the Sky Chapter 2" is itself a remake of an older title. Some players also reiterated the suggestion to add a Best Remake of the Year award, allowing different types of remastered works to compete within the same category.
Developed by Alkimia Interactive and published by THQ Nordic, "Gothic Remake" was previously nominated for Best Remake or Rerelease at the Golden Joystick Awards but ultimately lost to the updated version of "The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt." After launching on PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X/S, the game sold over 500,000 copies in its first week; its peak concurrent players on Steam reached 77,731, with a positive review rate exceeding 80%.
Compared to player reviews, Western media scores were more conservative: the PC version scored 74 on Metacritic, while the PS5 version scored 69. Technical issues, crashes, controversies surrounding the combat system, the PS5 Pro still being limited to 30 FPS, and the lack of traditional design elements like quest markers and hints were all cited as factors that may have influenced the ratings.
Currently, there is no official explanation for the review results.

