A conversation aimed at newcomers to the GTA series explored why GTA VI is generating so much buzz. Two authors familiar with the series argued that the key to keeping players coming back long-term remains the open world that allows free exploration and responds to player actions, though newcomers might remain unmoved after experiencing it themselves.
Looking back on the series’ evolution, they mentioned that the impact of GTA III at the time came from its persistent open-city experience. Players could drive, walk, and explore without frequently hitting level endpoints. By Grand Theft Auto IV, the series began adopting a more serious narrative, attempting to craft more mature characters and stories.
Both stated that Rockstar excels at creating dense, responsive open spaces. Players can constantly test the system, thereby discovering unexpected interactions, such as stealing trains or observing how accidents attract police and firefighters. When music, weather, and scenery coincidentally align, they can also form personalized cinematic scenes.
The conversation also touched on the series’ negative history. The respondents noted that some content previously “punched down” at vulnerable groups, and players could use the freedom systems to reenact egregious behaviors. Therefore, they did not claim that all newcomers would enjoy GTA VI, attributing its main appeal instead to freedom, environmental authenticity, systemic responsiveness, and the player’s ability to create their own stories.
Detailed report from foreign media:
On the eve of GTA VI’s arrival, across the entire site, every writer was preparing for a long sleepless night—
No, sorry, I won’t put you through that. But here at Kotaku, we’re all busy gearing up for intensive coverage of GTA VI over the next few days—or possibly weeks, even months! We’ve been talking about what we expect, what we hope to see, and our past experiences with the series. In the course of our conversation, it came up that, specifically, I had never actually played any GTA game. Not once, not even for a few minutes.
You can laugh, but I don’t think I’m the only one like this. Sure, Grand Theft Auto V has sold nearly 235 million copies, but there are about 3.5 billion gamers worldwide. Many of us have never played GTA V, nor any GTA title. But with GTA VI, we might start thinking that maybe we want to give it a try.
Standing on the outside this time was a strange experience. Through video clips, discussions, posts, and reviews, I had a vague idea of what GTA was, but I had never actually held a controller to experience firsthand what people were talking about when discussing one of the most popular games in history. This meant that although I had seen the trailers, I wasn’t really sure what to expect next. Don’t you just drive around? And steal stuff? Why do people care so much? I mean, I know why they care, but why do they care to this extent: buying five million copies every three months, taking a week off work, spending hundreds of dollars on a console, and ignoring their partners for days on end?
I brought in Kotaku’s two foremost GTA experts, Zack and Carolyn, to explain this phenomenon to me. I hope that everyone else out there sitting in the same easily stolen car as I am—and there are dozens of us!—can also benefit from their insights!
Rebekah Valentine asked, “What were your respective first experiences with GTA? How did you each start playing the series?”
Zack Zwiezen replied, “A friend brought over his PS2 copy of GTA III and started it up for me, and I was completely blown away. I was ten years old? Around that age. I remember walking around in that world, getting into a car, driving onto the streets, and never hitting a level-end screen or entering a mission. I could just keep exploring this big city. It was unlike anything I had played before. Later, I bought the game from that kid with my saved lunch money and spent countless hours playing GTA III. I’ve been a fan of the series ever since.”
Carolyn Petit replied, “I’d occasionally caught glimpses of those earliest top-down games here and there, but always just briefly; they didn’t really pique my interest. It wasn’t until Jeff Gerstmann published his GTA III review on GameSpot that I truly sat up and took notice. GameSpot was the gaming site I devoured at the time, and that review made the game sound like something special. I immediately went out and bought it. As soon as the game launched, I experienced that opening sequence: being rescued from a police armored vehicle and then having to escape through a dirty, dilapidated modern American city. In that moment, I knew I was witnessing gaming change forever. It felt similar to when I first saw Super Mario Bros. and ran to the right, or when I saw people lining up by placing quarters on top of the Street Fighter II arcade cabinet at my local 7-Eleven.”
Zack went on, “Over the years, I’ve gone back to play those earliest titles—the top-down ones. They were fun, but playing them now, it’s hard to imagine that these games would eventually spawn the biggest video game franchise in the world.”
Carolyn said, “Exactly! In many ways, GTA’s development into such a massive cultural phenomenon seems almost accidental. Those early games felt like novel curiosities that attracted attention through rebellion and transgression. They allowed players to role-play as criminals and kill civilians, so they garnered attention by ‘pushing boundaries,’ but as games, they weren’t actually that fun or interesting.”
Rebekah said, “I was raised in a Catholic family. Whenever my parents and teachers brought up GTA, they always described it as something full of sin. For many years, it was the target of widespread moral panic! My impression of it is obviously different now, and anyway, I don’t really care whether I’m playing a game about sin. But I must admit, viewing GTA through that lens for so many years indeed left me largely unaware of what else the game offered. For example, all these years, I’ve thought of it as a game where you drive around killing people, robbing, gambling, and picking up women. Though, maybe that’s actually quite accurate!”
Rebekah continued, “Now, I’m mature enough not to view it that way anymore. I originally thought the older games must have been much richer in content. But… maybe they weren’t? Using Carolyn’s words, when do you think these games started becoming ‘fun and interesting’?”
Carolyn said, “After GTA III came out, I admit I couldn’t get enough of it. But it wasn’t because I loved the crime story it told. The story served its purpose, but it wasn’t particularly outstanding. What truly defined my experience with GTA III were the emergent encounters I had in the game. They created moments that were genuinely beautiful. I remember once, I was driving in-game, it started raining, and Fade Away was playing on the radio. It felt like an incredibly cinematic scene, as if catching a glimpse of beauty amidst urban decay. That’s mainly what stuck with me from the first game—well, actually the third, but you get the idea. Of course, testing the limits of what the game allowed, messing around, figuring out how to steal a tank, and so on, was also incredibly fun. This game gave players an environment and a system that encouraged free play, something no other game I’d played before had achieved.”
Zack said, “GTA can clearly be divided into three distinct eras. It has always been an open-world game where players can do whatever they want, and that remains the biggest draw to this day. But in the top-down era, the games felt more cartoonish and zany. It wasn’t until the 3D era, when the games moved to the PS2, that they started becoming a bit more mature. Still, while GTA III had a great atmosphere, it was still a very goofy game at times. It felt like everyone inside was just pretending to be gangsters, cops, or criminals.”
Zack continued, “GTA IV kicked off the ‘HD era,’ and this is when GTA truly began evolving into what it is today. Starting with Niko’s journey in GTA IV, the games became more serious and began attempting to tell more mature stories centered on believable characters. I don’t think Grand Theft Auto V nailed this aspect as well as GTA IV did, but if you’re asking when they stopped being just ‘driving around and shooting at cops,’ I’d say this was roughly the turning point.”
Zack continued, “But for me—I’m not sure about Carolyn’s take—I keep going back to GTA and getting excited for each new release not because I want to see what story Rockstar tells next. What I really want is that world, to live in that virtual space and explore it. That’s the real draw. A major reason is that Rockstar is far better than other developers at crafting detailed, massive, and vibrant open worlds.”
Carolyn said, “Oh, totally agree. To be clear, I do enjoy certain parts of some GTA stories. I think San Andreas had some interesting themes about police corruption and attempted to touch on the pressure-cooker social environment of 1990s Los Angeles. I’m not saying it handled these topics perfectly or offered particularly insightful commentary. But at the time, just seeing a game willing to attempt it was refreshing. Also, that game had some individually well-written characters and moments. Amidst the chaos and killing, there were also small moments of beauty. And yes, GTA IV remains my favorite story in the series. Niko carries some heavy baggage, and his quest for revenge leads to outcomes that deeply moved me. But yes, in my view, what has always elevated GTA games to another level is their worlds. These worlds emit an environmental authenticity that far exceeds what most other games offer. Seriously, since GTA III, what makes a moment most memorable for me in a GTA game has hardly changed. Usually, it’s just being in the right place at the right time, with the radio playing the right song, creating an impeccable atmosphere. Maybe the sunset hitting the sea just right, or something else. That feeling always strikes me as astonishingly beautiful.”
Rebekah asked, “Perhaps the answer to this question is just repeating what you two have already said. But I mean, okay, I understand why these games are special, but why are they special to this degree? Why does Grand Theft Auto V sell five million copies every three months? Why is the entire internet going absolutely crazy for GTA VI? I mean, I get it—they’re technically impressive, the freedom is cool, there’s lots of content in online mode, and so on. But what is it that makes these games receive attention and spark frenzy far beyond any other game? Is it just because of what you described earlier, because it’s really that good? Do I have to experience it myself to understand? Because I feel like I’ve had moments like the ones you described in other games too!”
Carolyn said, “I think it’s undeniable that for a large portion of people, those ugly aspects have often been a significant part of the appeal. Back in the GTA III era, groups of guys would laugh with friends while showing off how they picked up a sex worker, ‘had sex’ with her, and then killed her to get their money back. I remember watching a Grand Theft Auto V gameplay video on YouTube years ago—I think it’s been deleted since—where the player was just attacking transgender sex workers in the game. These characters were clearly designed to be mocked, and there were comments underneath saying things like ‘you’re doing God’s work.’ GTA does have an ugly side, which cannot be ignored, and I do believe this contributed to its success to some extent. But that doesn’t represent the whole series. Also, I think the series’ success lies in—well, I’m sure you’ve had similar experiences in other games. Maybe you’ll play GTA VI and just shrug, saying, ‘Yeah, this isn’t anything special.’ Of course, if you truly feel that way, it’s perfectly reasonable. But for me, at least, it’s always been the worlds, the details, and the incredibly careful selection of soundtrack music. Combined, these elements create an experience that immerses you in a modern American setting. Other games, like the Saints Row series, simply can’t come close to that.”
Zack said, “Yes. For most of its history, the GTA series has punched down at vulnerable groups, with players using these games to reenact terrorist attacks, target women, or do other terrible things. It wasn’t until RDR2—which isn’t GTA, but shares a lot with it—that I felt Rockstar started trying to move away from that crap.”
Zack continued, “That said, Rockstar is simply the best at making open worlds. Players are rewarded for trying all sorts of things everywhere.”
Zack continued, “Stephen Totilo, in his Grand Theft Auto V review, accurately captured the idea that for players, the gameplay is almost like a treasure hunt. But you’re not looking for scattered items or plastic eggs. What players are really searching for are things to do, details worth staring at, and elements to interact with.”
Zack continued, “I remember in San Andreas, I drove up to a stopped train, pressed the triangle button to see if the game would let me steal it… and it did! I drove that train for about 20 minutes. Then I wondered, what happens if I go too fast? I cranked the speed up as high as it would go, and the train flew off the tracks! Moments like these are everywhere in these games. Rockstar provides a sandbox full of possibilities, and most of the time, the games act like a good improv comedian, building on your ideas with ‘Yes, and…’”
Carolyn said, “Yes, there are no limits to what you can do, so you get both a lot of ugly behavior and a lot of purely creative gameplay. This kind of gameplay is more about testing how the world reacts to the player’s actions.”
Zack said, “I remember in Grand Theft Auto V, I shot at that big blimp. It exploded, crashed to the ground, started a fire, and then fire trucks arrived, and the police were alerted. Being able to do that felt insane. And I’d bet many players have never done that!”
Carolyn said, “Haha, I’ve never done that!”
Rebekah said, “Haha, okay, I admit I look forward to causing some chaos. What you’re saying reminds me of a story I heard… gosh, I can’t remember who told it, which feels a bit embarrassing. It was either Andrew Eiche or Devin Reimer from Owlchemy Labs. They told me that when people playtested their games, the developers would say nothing, just watch quietly. Unless someone tried something and then made a disappointed sound. At that point, they’d always ask, ‘What did you expect to happen?’ and jot down the answer. If they could add what the player expected into the final version, they would.”
Carolyn said, “The open-world content will still be the main attraction. But I admit, now that we’re on the brink of GTA VI’s release, I hope the story this game tells can match its world in certain ways. For example, treating characters more like flesh-and-blood people than past GTA stories, and including less misogynistic content. I think there will always be tension between open-world shenanigans and storytelling. Honestly, I think that tension can be interesting too. But yes, I hope the extremely vile and unnecessary ugliness I encounter in GTA VI will be less frequent than what I often saw in previous entries.”
Rebekah said, “Changing the subject slightly, which GTA is definitively the best so far? For instance, if I had time to play one before jumping into VI—though I don’t, but let’s pretend I do—which one should I pick?”
Rebekah followed up, “On the flip side, which one is the worst?”
Zack said, “Considering I know you and understand what you like and dislike in games, I’d recommend GTA IV. Although Grand Theft Auto V is technically more impressive, IV has a more unified tone and story. Plus, Niko doesn’t make you feel disgusted the way the three main protagonists in Grand Theft Auto V sometimes do.”
Zack continued, “The worst game is GTA Advance.”
Rebekah asked, “Haha, why?”
Zack replied, “They tried to make GTA III on the Game Boy Advance.”
Zack continued, “It didn’t turn out well.”
Carolyn said, “Yes, and in my opinion, the GTA IV soundtrack is still the best to this day. If we’re talking about the highest average number of hit songs, it might still be Vice City. But GTA IV introduced me to the most good music I hadn’t heard before, and it did the most to make the game’s world feel culturally rich and exciting.”
Zack said, “Driving through Liberty City at night with New York Groove playing in my ears. It was wonderful.”
Carolyn exclaimed, “Oh—my—god!”
Zack said, “Don’t think about the fact that the song mentions New York, a city that doesn’t actually exist in GTA.”
Carolyn said, “Haha, I actually quite enjoy the strange blurring of lines between reality and fiction. The game has to acknowledge: ‘Look, we all know where this place in the game actually is, even if it’s not called New York.’”
Rebekah asked, “I’ve read a lot about what’s new in GTA VI. But from a fan’s perspective, what new things in GTA VI excite you the most?”
Carolyn said, “I’m very eager to see how they handle Lucia, especially given the series’ history of misogyny. The thought of finally having a fully realized, playable female protagonist in a 3D GTA excites me, but also makes me quite wary. However, most importantly, there’s a new world to explore. This world seems to leverage technological advances to become the most detailed and immersive world in the series to date. I just want to live in it, explore it, see what surprises it holds, which details catch my eye or make me marvel, and what emergent gameplay moments arise from the game systems.”
Zack said, "For me, it comes back to what we discussed earlier: the world. I'll finish the story, complete all the missions, and so on. But what will keep me coming back for weeks, months, or even years is the world itself. I still occasionally fire up GTA IV just to drive around the city. I also return to Red Dead Redemption 2 to hunt deer, visit rivers I haven't explored before, and go fishing. These places are so rich in detail, packed with things to see and places to go, that you could easily spend years experiencing them all gradually. Now Rockstar is about to launch another open world, and I'm practically going crazy with excitement."
Carolyn said, "Right. I feel like Rockstar's worlds have this sense of possibility that I don't find in most other games. It reminds me of all the urban legends spawned by San Andreas, with people claiming they saw various things in the game. I think that was partly due to that specific era in gaming history. Back then, such massive open worlds were still very new and exciting. Combined with the technology of the time, no matter how many 'real-world' details were included, these worlds always felt a bit dreamlike and surreal. But that sense of possibility has persisted in some way. You just never know what might happen or what you might discover. I love that about it."
Zack said, "Exactly. I remember exploring the forests in San Andreas as a kid, thinking, 'Bigfoot might be right here.' These games feel so vast and expansive that, just like in the real world, it's easy to start imagining strange creatures and mysteries lurking in the dark corners between cities and missions. That's also part of GTA's appeal. You feel like there's something you haven't seen yet behind that hill. Behind that building. It's waiting for you to discover it. It's incredibly exciting. I can't wait to boot up GTA VI and feel that sensation again."
Rebekah asked, "Okay, last question: When I start playing GTA VI, I'll obviously follow the story at first. But if I want to truly experience how 'GTA' it all is, what would you recommend I do in the early stages?"
Rebekah continued, "And don't just say 'explore the world.' What specifically should I do in this world to really feel the vibe you're describing?"
Zack replied, "Find a car, pick a direction, and just drive smoothly in that direction to see if anything catches your eye. Maybe a tall tower, a dilapidated building, a cool car, or a group of people hanging out. Then go check it out. You'll likely stumble upon some random scene or detail that surprises you. The core of GTA games is that you can go anywhere and try anything, and the game will react in some way. So I suggest you just test the waters of this world. GTA VI will be the most expensive sandbox ever made available for play, and that's exactly what I plan to do!"
Carolyn replied, "I think that feeling will find you on its own. If you tune into what the game is trying to convey, that sensation will wash over you. Just follow your heart and live in this world however you wish. For me, the radio is often a big part of the initial experience. I'll constantly switch stations to appreciate the variety of music and the cultures it represents. Then there are the early story missions, which help me understand: 'Okay, who are these characters I'm controlling? What are they like? What problems are they facing? What are their goals?' At least in the games with stronger narratives, these elements often immerse me early on. I hope Jason and Lucia rank among the series' best protagonists. But honestly, I think the best approach is to see what catches your attention and follow it. For me, part of it might be that I really enjoy driving, and since I don't have a car in real life, I do tend to just drive around aimlessly and listen to the radio. But for you, it might be something else entirely. I'd love to know if it resonates with you."
Carolyn added, "Haha, looks like Zack and I can't escape saying 'Explore the world!' no matter how we phrase it. But I think everyone explores differently, focuses on different things, and has their own unique way of exploring."
Zack said, "Yes! But that's the beauty of these games. Everyone finds their own story, their own moments. I really can't wait to talk to you and others about this game after we've all played it for hours upon hours. That's almost as fun as playing GTA itself. Discussing it with others and sharing our individual stories."

