The potential direction for Red Dead Redemption 3 has recently sparked discussion among players, with two main ideas emerging: creating another prequel or launching a standalone story with new characters. Rockstar Games has not yet announced this game.
One of the focal points of discussion is whether the existing timeline can still be naturally extended. The story of Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in 1899, while the first game advances the timeline to 1911, with the stories of Dutch van der Linde and John Marston already fairly comprehensively addressed. As a result, some players believe that concluded stories should not be reopened merely for the sake of releasing a sequel.
If the narrative continues with Jack Marston's experiences, the setting would shift into World War I or the 1920s, potentially diluting the game's Western characteristics. Another possibility is to look further back, depicting the Van der Linde gang at its peak and concluding with the Blackwater incident, which was not directly shown in Red Dead Redemption 2.
Regarding the prequel approach, critics worry that knowing the outcome will diminish suspense, while supporters counter with the success of Red Dead Redemption 2. Another widely accepted direction is to set the story between the 1850s and 1880s, introducing new characters independent of the Marston family to refocus on the golden age of the West. Some players would prefer Rockstar to revive other older franchises instead.

