As the popularity of many classic IPs declines and new IPs struggle to gain traction, Hollywood has turned its eyes to video games, attempting to create box office hits. This includes successes like Minecraft, which performed exceptionally well at the box office, as well as failures like Borderlands, which flopped both critically and commercially. Yet, many top-tier game IPs have yet to hit the big screen, with Grand Theft Auto being the most representative example. Will this situation change?
This week, Hollywood industry media The Ankler provided a negative answer. Multiple sources told the outlet that Rockstar Games has no interest in a film adaptation project for GTA. To some extent, this makes sense—the core direction of the GTA series is integrating cinematic storytelling into open-world systemic gameplay. Reversing this process, turning the core of such a game into a movie, would be like taking the game version of Indiana Jones and turning it back into a live-action film—completely unnecessary.
However, Rockstar, under Take-Two, seems inclined to sell the film/TV adaptation rights for its western open-world IP, Red Dead Redemption. The Ankler further revealed that previous licensing offers for Red Dead Redemption reached as high as $100 million. The report also noted that Amazon spent $250 million to secure the TV adaptation rights for The Lord of the Rings.
Red Dead Redemption's positioning is quite similar to The Last of Us—HBO successfully adapted the latter into a critically acclaimed and highly popular series without disappointing game fans. It's easy to imagine that top streaming platforms would likely be interested in this Rockstar IP, with executives probably already preparing proposals by referencing the critical success of Deadwood and the commercial热度 (heat/popularity) of Yellowstone.
Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick, formerly COO of 20th Century Fox, stated in an interview on The David Rubenstein Show on November 12: "We are very cautious about expanding our IPs because we are fundamentally a creative company. Our goal is to create the highest quality entertainment content in the world—works we can always be proud of. We will only proceed with film or TV adaptations when the creative team is passionate about the project and believes it will resonate with and delight players. This threshold is very high. Of course, the risk of failure always exists. So while we don't rule out adaptations, our choices are extremely careful."
He had already explained this decision logic in detail to shareholders during the "Barbenheimer" boom in Hollywood in 2023.
"The success rate in the film industry is far lower than in interactive entertainment. Our console games have a success rate of 80% to 90%. Even well-run film companies only have a success rate of around 30%—meaning there's a 70% chance that any movie we license for adaptation will fail. Even if an adaptation succeeds, the boost to our net profit... while not zero, is negligible compared to our core business. But if an adaptation fails, we bear the risk of damaging the value of the IP itself."
Currently, the competition among major studios to adapt popular game IPs has reached a fever pitch. According to The Ankler, Amazon, Netflix, and FX are developing series based on Tomb Raider, Assassin's Creed, and Far Cry, with per-episode production costs ranging from $15 million to $25 million—essentially matching the budget levels of mid-range Hollywood films.
But Take-Two is not in a hurry to streamify its IPs. Especially after the Borderlands movie bombed both critically and commercially, the company's caution is well-founded—the film's production began before Take-Two acquired the series' developer, Gearbox Entertainment. After all, the sales and revenue records of the games themselves are at heights Hollywood can hardly reach (GTA VI's first-day revenue surpassed Avengers: Endgame). Why risk damaging core IPs for marginal business income? A high-quality Red Dead Redemption series might help sell an extra 10 million copies of the game, but a bad movie could severely damage the IP's reputation among audiences beyond traditional gamers.
Last year, Dan Houser, co-founder of Rockstar who left to start his own entertainment company, discussed past negotiations for film adaptations: "They thought we would be blinded by fame and fortune, but that wasn't the case. We hold IPs worth billions of dollars; the returns from film adaptations are simply not proportional, and the risks are completely unbalanced. Back then, the general consensus was that movie adaptations of games were poorly made trash."
In 2008, Max Payne, developed by Remedy and published by Rockstar, received a live-action film adaptation starring Mark Wahlberg. The film had mediocre box office results but terrible reviews, holding only a 15% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. This setback didn't kill the franchise—Max Payne 3 was released later, and remasters of the first two games are currently in development. However, it's clear that Rockstar and Take-Two have no desire to repeat past mistakes. This is especially true now, as traditional film studios decline and game companies emerge as new giants in the entertainment industry.

