The latest German TÜV Annual Vehicle Inspection Report shows that the major defect rate for the Model Y in the 2- to 3-year-old vehicle group has risen to 18.5%, ranking last among all models for two consecutive years.
TÜV stated that since the 2015 annual report, no vehicle aged 2 to 3 years has ever shown such a high rate of major defects.
According to the report, the data is based on approximately 9.7 million vehicle inspections conducted at German TÜV inspection stations between July 1, 2025, and June 30, 2026. This translates to nearly one in five Model Ys undergoing their first periodic technical inspection being found to have major or dangerous defects requiring attention.
Regarding specific issues, the Model Y's most prominent weakness is its suspension system. The frequency of defects such as wear and looseness in load-bearing ball joints and guide joints was 24 times higher than that of comparable models.
The braking system also performed poorly, with 3.4% of Model Ys found to have brake disc defects, compared to a group average of just 1.0%. The failure rate for front lighting systems was also above average.
It should be noted that the inspected Model Ys had an average mileage of 58,000 km, higher than the group average of 47,000 km.
Additionally, the Tesla Model 3 also performed poorly, ranking third from the bottom with a defect rate of 12.5%.
In the 6- to 7-year-old vehicle group, the Model 3 ranked last with a defect rate of 27.9%, compared to the group average of 13.2%. The SAIC MG4 came in second-to-last with a 16.0% defect rate, becoming the first Chinese-brand model to appear in the TÜV annual report, with its main issues also centered on brake discs.
It is worth noting that poor rankings are not typical for all electric vehicles. In the 2- to 3-year-old vehicle group, 26 pure electric models were evaluated. Four electric vehicles—the Mazda MX-30, Audi Q8 e-tron, Mini Cooper SE, and Mercedes-Benz EQA—made it into the top ten overall. The group champion was the Mazda CX-60, with a defect rate of 2.3%.
Joachim Bühler, General Manager of TÜV Association, explained that suspension and brakes are common issues for electric vehicles. The battery weight continuously stresses the suspension, while regenerative braking significantly reduces the use of mechanical brakes, making brake discs prone to rust.
ADAC also pointed out that Tesla does not set maintenance intervals, so many defects are only discovered during annual inspections, which has somewhat influenced the statistical results.

