Skip to main content

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Co-op DLC Receives Mostly Negative Reviews Due to Poor Experience

Co-op gameplay fits The Binding of Isaac extremely well. Looking back now, it's hard to imagine what this game would be like without co-op mode. However, the stability of the co-op feature has never been ideal since its launch.

The free DLC "Repentance+", which added co-op functionality, entered testing in 2024 and has been plagued by netcode issues since its launch, with frequent desynchronization and disconnections. When I played, selecting Bethany for co-op would always kick me back to the lobby; using The Lost to restart against The Lamb resulted in disconnections every single time. Therefore, I had been eagerly anticipating its official release, even if all the attention on November 19th was stolen by GTA VI.

《以撒的结合》联机DLC体验糟糕 收获玩家多半差评

I originally thought these bugs were normal issues for a beta version and would be fixed with the official 1.0 release. Unfortunately, things didn't go as planned. Co-op mode remains an excellent way to experience The Binding of Isaac, and I've made many precious memories: grinding maps with my girlfriend at 2 AM, accidentally blowing her up with my Brimstone build, or ruining my mixed Brimstone build with Blood Tears, while she beat Silence as easily as Little Larry. However, the official release is still plagued by netcode issues and frequent desynchronization. In fact, the patch notes on launch day didn't even mention fixing disconnections due to desync.

As expected, this DLC received a wave of negative reviews upon launch, with recent ratings dropping directly to "Mostly Negative" on Steam.

A dissatisfied player commented: "For a whole year, Repentance+ had not a single decent update, staying completely silent with zero promotion. Then, a week before the update, they tried to ride the GTA VI hype on X, posting old memes to grab traffic—only to deliver this pile of garbage in the end."

Another player demanded: "Completely redo the netcode! The core of this update is the co-op feature. I played on Switch 2, and the experience was ridiculously bad. Whether connected via 5G or Ethernet, input latency was normal, but there was constant desynchronization and disconnection. Once I finally managed to join a room, the game just froze."

Another player commented: "I really don't get it. This 'official release' is basically no different from the beta version a year ago, just adding some GTA-related content and a bunch of new bugs. After waiting a whole year with zero updates, the game state is worse than before. What's the point? I know they're working on the port of Meow Gene, but this is just too perfunctory."

The fix list included in the official release of "Repentance+" at least has some content, but the PC launch wasn't the focus of this update. The real highlight was that this DLC finally launched on console platforms. But absurdly, Steam players can get it for free, while PlayStation, Switch, and Xbox players have to pay for it.

Waiting two years only for this result is more than just disappointing. The co-op mode of The Binding of Isaac was supposed to be a great reason to revisit this roguelike classic and play for hundreds more hours. But the stability of the multiplayer mode is ridiculously poor: the super-strong build you spent hours stacking ends up failing not because of bad luck or lack of skill, but due to desynchronization and netcode issues. Under these circumstances, it's really hard to recommend "Repentance+", especially when it costs $10.