Minecraft Dungeons 2 review scores are out: IGN gives it a 6, GameSpot a 7. MTC has collected reviews from 26 media outlets for the Xbox version, with a current average score of 76.
IGN Score: 6, Okay
Minecraft Dungeons 2 is a shallow ARPG sequel that offers a few evenings of mindless dungeon-delving fun, but little else.
Verdict
Minecraft Dungeons 2 is a very shallow action RPG that provides a few evenings of casual dungeon exploration fun, but lacks substance beyond that. Aside from the new Sift Realm—which features some cool new concepts and noteworthy creatures—this sequel doesn't offer much. It underutilizes Minecraft's iconic setting, feeling like a reskin of a mediocre Diablo-like game with a thin narrative and superficial hack-and-slash combat. This low-risk action game is fine for killing time, especially for players intimidated by complex menus and building systems, but otherwise, it doesn't have much to offer.
IGN Review Video:
GameSpot: 7/10
It's understandable that Minecraft Dungeons 2 doesn't completely overhaul its predecessor. The original game was already an accessible and fun dungeon crawler, even if it leaned towards easier difficulty. Dungeons 2 builds on this foundation by adding depth, connecting the game world to the broader Minecraft universe, and introducing a robust economy system, more flexible building mechanics, and additional post-game content.
Despite the restrictive Emerald Cap, scarce enchanted books, and some technical issues that somewhat impacted my experience, the differences between the two games are clear. Minecraft Dungeons is a charming entry point into dungeon crawlers, while Minecraft Dungeons 2 crafts a deeper action RPG within the familiar blocky framework. Although it doesn't fully escape the limitations of its predecessor, Minecraft Dungeons 2, as a more ambitious sequel, finally brings greater depth to its loot, building, and world, even if some flaws remain.
Pros
Stronger connection to the Minecraft universe
More diverse building options
Plenty of post-game activities
Cons
Restrictive Emerald Cap
Scarce materials limit building experimentation
Numerous significant bugs
