Following the release of the campaign for Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, the differing portrayals of John Price in the original and rebooted "Modern Warfare" series have become a focal point of player discussion. Some community members believe that this installment concludes the character arc of the rebooted Price, earning Barry Sloane's portrayal recognition comparable to the classic version.
The classic version of Price, voiced by Billy Murray, is described as a tough, charismatic, and battle-hardened old-school commander. His deep voice, boonie hat, and cigar have also become highly recognizable symbols of the character in the early series.
Barry Sloane's portrayal of the rebooted Price is more grounded in reality and exhibits greater depth. This tactical commander must make choices between his duties, the moral dilemmas of modern localized conflicts, and caring for the members of Task Force 141.
Summarizing player opinions, the value of the reboot lies not in imitating the original, but in establishing a different yet recognizable version of Price for a new generation of players. However, the notion of "becoming a legend twice" is a subjective evaluation by players and writers regarding character development, rather than an officially confirmed objective conclusion.