The release of before-and-after graphics comparisons for "The Witcher 3: Remastered" has sparked controversy, with some players arguing that the new version diminishes the original's atmosphere. CDPR subsequently confirmed that players can continue playing the original 2015 release.
CDPR unveiled this visual and technical upgrade during the Opening Night Live at Gamescom 2026, planning a September 29 release and offering it free of charge to players who already own the base game and both expansions. The new version targets PC and current-generation consoles, continuing the graphical updates the game received in 2022.
The controversy centers on comparison footage of a fight against a Drowner in a swamp. Some players feel that the new version's white, greenish lighting replaces the original's orange tones; while the image is clearer, it lacks the previous sense of gloom and dampness. Other players pointed out that fire reflections from the Igni sign on water and vegetation, as well as the subtle textures of Geralt's skin and armor, appeared less pronounced in the comparison clip than in the original.
The new version introduces technologies such as path tracing and NVIDIA DLSS 4.5, with improvements to vegetation density and building textures. Discussions surrounding the comparison footage reveal that players have varying preferences regarding more accurate lighting effects versus the original game's artistic atmosphere.
In response to criticism, CDPR stated that the content shown in the comparison clips is still under development and promised that the final release will offer a rich set of graphical settings, allowing players to adjust the visual effects themselves. The remaster also plans to adjust combat balance, movement mechanics, and the skill tree, changes that have also raised concerns among some players.
CDPR confirmed that the remastered version will not forcibly replace the original. PC players can continue using the old version of the game, retaining the option to play with existing mods.